By Dr. Al Philip-Neri
When I became director of a state facility for girls, one of my first jobs was building a supervisory team. I promoted the staff I respected most: people who were excellent at working with inmates. It was a mistake.
Being good with inmates and being able to lead staff require different skills. The people I promoted knew how to make decisions about inmate functions. Most had no idea how to make decisions for the facility. Nobody had taught them, and I had assumed the first skill would carry over to the second. Leaders tend to promote what they value. I valued skill with inmates because it was my own strength.
I was young. I didn’t have a PhD or the language I have now to describe what was happening. What I had was a facility that needed leaders and supervisors who needed more from me than a promotion.
The transition from strong officer to effective supervisor is where many new supervisors struggle. It is also where agencies have the most control.
Addressing problems before they escalate
As an officer, you are responsible for a unit, a pod or a cellhouse. Get promoted to sergeant, and you may be responsible for several units at once. Keep moving up, and eventually you may be running the entire facility during your shift. The scope of your decisions changes. Your instincts don’t automatically change with it.
One evening, while I was serving as a lieutenant, an inmate set off the sprinkler system in his pod. I ordered the evacuation of the entire facility.
Nobody questioned the decision because I was highly respected. But during the debrief, I acknowledged that I had overreacted and took responsibility for it. A problem in one pod did not require moving the entire population.
Under pressure, people default to whatever made them successful. For me, that was decisiveness. Being decisive is not the same as exercising sound judgment across an entire facility. And when a respected leader gets it wrong, nobody else may say so. The leader must.
Before the promotion
You must graduate from high school before you enter college. Leadership should work the same way. Officers should prepare for supervision before they test for promotion, not after they get the stripes.
When I served on the Colorado DOC Statewide Special Operations Response Team, passing tryouts didn’t make you a member. You served as an intern until you completed the academy, giving the team an opportunity to see how you performed before you became a full member.
Agencies can build a similar path. Invite interested officers to raise their hands early. Give them acting assignments with real responsibility. Have a supervisor observe and debrief them. Gather feedback from the peers and supervisors who work beside them because the floor often sees what administration doesn’t. Then let them enter the promotional process.
Along the way, look for three things beyond being a strong officer:
- Can they see past their own unit?
- Can they hold a standard with a peer?
- When someone pushes back, do they explain the standard or lean on their position?
The first 90 days
At the girls’ facility, the fix wasn’t a class. I spent time with my supervisors. I led from the front. I kept an open-door policy and meant it. I was on the floor and in the mix because they needed to see how I handled situations and set expectations.
It helped, but developing them was a work in progress. One of the hardest challenges was teaching supervisors to move beyond the pettiness, personal biases and cliques that exist in correctional environments. Strong individual performers don’t automatically become effective supervisors. They must learn to put the facility’s objectives ahead of personal relationships and preferences.
As a lieutenant, I spent time with my sergeants, but I also gave them authority to make decisions. Supervisors don’t learn judgment by watching someone else exercise it. They learn it by owning decisions.
Here is how I would structure those first 90 days today.
Days 1–30: Change the view
Assign each new supervisor an experienced mentor and hold a standing weekly meeting. Have them visit every unit under their supervision. Plan their first accountability conversation with a former peer instead of waiting for it to happen in front of the shift.
Days 31–60: Give real authority, then debrief it
Let new supervisors make real decisions, then help them examine those decisions afterward. Four questions are enough: What did you see? What did you decide? What else did it affect? What would you do differently?
Days 61–90: Practice at the next level
Walk new supervisors through scenarios that require facility-level decisions. Gather feedback from the staff who work for them. Then set specific development priorities for the remainder of their first year.
When a new supervisor struggles
Problems show up early if command staff know what to look for: avoiding difficult conversations with former peers, leaning on rank instead of explaining the standard, enforcing rules inconsistently based on relationships and making decisions without considering facility-wide consequences.
When conflicts or performance problems arose among supervisors or staff, I intervened quickly. I brought the people involved together, made sure each person understood the bigger picture and the common objective, and worked toward a solution that served the whole facility. Nobody left without a clear understanding of how things would proceed. Sometimes I followed up individually to reinforce the lesson. Formal discipline was rarely necessary, but I used it when warranted.
That approach works because alignment precedes accountability. You can’t fairly hold someone to a standard they don’t understand. New supervisors need clear expectations, opportunities to correct mistakes and the confidence to address problems before they escalate.
The bottom line
Organizations don’t execute. People do. Every new supervisor will make mistakes. I made mine. What matters is whether the agency prepared them and whether they take responsibility when they get something wrong. Promotion gives someone authority. Preparation determines what they can do with it when the pressure is real.
| NEXT: The new sergeant’s dilemma: Navigating the transition from line staff to first-line supervision
About the author
Dr. Al Philip-Neri, Ph.D., spent more than a decade in the Colorado Division of Youth Corrections and Colorado Department of Corrections, serving as a Correctional Officer I, II and III, certified use-of-force instructor, and member of the Colorado DOC Statewide Special Operations Response Team. He also served within the Youthful Offender System, Colorado’s pioneering correctional program for violent juvenile offenders sentenced as adults.
Following his corrections career, Dr. Al led Jefferson County’s post-Columbine multi-agency school violence response initiative, coordinating law enforcement, fire service and school district partners in the development of active violence response and use-of-force protocols. He later returned to corrections as director of a statewide juvenile correctional facility.
Dr. Al earned his doctorate in Performance Psychology and is the founder of Cohesion HQ, a performance advisory firm that helps leaders build organizations that align, sharpen, and execute. He is the author of “The Execution Advantage: How Leaders Build Organizations That Drive Results.”