Trending Topics

Unresolved unit problems need more than a log entry

How correctional supervisors can ensure unresolved problems don’t get lost between shifts

Correctional Officers Reviewing Facility Data.png

Image/ChatGPT

By Dr. Danny L. McGuire, Jr.

Consider a hypothetical housing unit where a shower has been taken out of service. The immediate hazard has been addressed under facility procedures, maintenance has been notified and a supervisor has authorized an alternative arrangement for shower access. The outgoing shift records that maintenance is aware of the problem.

The next shift receives that entry but little else. Officers cannot confirm which arrangement remains in effect, who is checking on the repair or when they should expect an update. People in custody ask about access and receive different answers. An officer reports the problem again. By the following shift, staff are repeating the same conversation while the repair remains unresolved.

The initial response happened. Supervisory responsibility did not carry forward clearly enough for the unit to function consistently.

In my previous Corrections1 article, “Before you lead the unit, learn to lead yourself,” I examined self-command under pressure. [1] That responsibility continues after the difficult moment has passed. A calm supervisor must also establish what happens to unfinished work when relief arrives.

In “Hard Reset: Reliability Under Pressure,” I describe reliability as maintaining professional standards when circumstances become difficult. [2] In a correctional facility, those standards must survive interruptions, competing demands and changes in personnel. The people working or living on the unit still need answers after the supervisor who first heard the concern has gone home.

Give the unresolved problem a next action

A log entry documents what happened. It should also help the next supervisor identify what still needs attention. “Maintenance notified” leaves several operational questions unanswered.

In the shower example, the approved record should identify the current condition, the authorized temporary arrangement and the outstanding action. The receiving supervisor should know who will follow up with maintenance and when that check is due. If the repair cannot be completed promptly, someone must review whether the temporary arrangement remains workable.

Use the facility’s existing reporting and tracking systems. A separate notebook or unofficial spreadsheet can leave the next shift working from an incomplete picture. Put information where authorized staff are expected to find it, and preserve required records.

The National Institute of Corrections’ guide to correctional leadership competencies emphasizes clear expectations, information sharing and communication that recipients understand. It also identifies communicating barriers to managers as a supervisory responsibility. [3] That guidance provides a foundation for making an unresolved concern actionable.

Match the next action to the risk. An immediate threat requires action under the facility’s emergency procedures. A routine repair that remains unresolved still needs a review time and a responsible person. Logging a concern cannot substitute for action required by policy or by the conditions officers are confronting.

Confirm who has accepted responsibility

At shift change, identify the supervisor taking responsibility for follow-up. A useful exchange in the hypothetical example might be: “The shower remains out of service. The approved access arrangement is in the unit record. Maintenance has not confirmed a repair time. Will you check its status and review the arrangement before the next scheduled shower period?”

The receiving supervisor should confirm the assignment and clarify anything that is missing. If that person cannot carry it out, determine who can through the appropriate chain of command. An instruction to “pass it along” can otherwise move through several shifts without reaching anyone who believes the task belongs to them.

This does not mean the outgoing supervisor must remain personally available around the clock. It means responsibility transfers deliberately. The facility needs continuity that works when a particular supervisor is off duty, on leave or assigned elsewhere.

Be equally clear when another department controls the solution. Maintenance may be responsible for the repair, but custody staff still need to know its status and manage the effect on unit operations. Confirm the receiving contact and the next step without assuming that submitting a request settles the matter.

Keep the unit response consistent

People in custody experience a disrupted service continuously, even as staff rotate. They should receive an accurate explanation of the current arrangement, within security and confidentiality limits. Officers need the same information so they can carry out the authorized plan.

In the hypothetical unit, an officer might explain: “That shower is still out of service. This is the approved arrangement for access while repairs are pending. We do not yet have a confirmed repair time.”

The officer should describe the actual arrangement rather than promise that the next shift will fix the problem.

If conditions require a change, obtain the necessary authorization, record the reason and communicate the revision. Consistency means staff can explain why the current direction applies. It does not require preserving a temporary plan that has become unsafe or unworkable.

When questions recur, check the unresolved condition before treating them as a challenge to authority. Address misconduct through the proper process while continuing to address the underlying service issue. Keep established request and grievance procedures available; an informal supervisory response should not replace them.

For supervisors, this is a practical application of service. Officers need usable direction, and people in custody need the institution to carry out its responsibilities. Both suffer when an avoidable information gap becomes a recurring confrontation.

Verify the result before closing the concern

A completed work order is a reason to check the unit’s status. Confirm through the appropriate personnel that the work has been completed and the affected service is authorized to resume. Do not ask officers to make technical determinations beyond their training or authority.

Then communicate the change to the staff who must act on it. In the shower example, that includes identifying when normal access resumes and whether the temporary arrangement has ended. Update the record so the next shift does not continue an obsolete restriction.

Tell the officer who raised the concern what was done. If the repair is incomplete or the reported problem persists, keep the concern active and establish the next action. An accurate record of unfinished work is more useful than a closed item that officers know remains unresolved.

The same discipline applies when the answer is a decision rather than a repair. If officers report conflicting unit instructions, obtain clarification from the appropriate authority, communicate it across affected shifts and confirm that staff understand which instruction now governs. A reply in one supervisor’s inbox does not reach every officer expected to follow it.

Escalate recurring problems with their operational cost

Some obstacles require resources or decisions beyond the unit supervisor’s authority. Repeatedly carrying the same entry forward should prompt a closer look at what is preventing resolution.

Document when the concern began, what has been attempted and how the unresolved condition is affecting the unit. Include the effects of any temporary arrangement, such as additional staff assignments or interruptions to scheduled activities. Distinguish confirmed effects from anticipated risks, and identify the decision or assistance needed.

Bring that information through the appropriate chain of command. A report that identifies the recurring problem and the specific obstacle gives leadership something concrete to address. Continue required escalation if conditions worsen; a previously submitted request does not resolve a changed risk.

Command staff have a corresponding responsibility to respond. Supervisors need to know whether resources have been authorized, a different plan is required or further information is needed. A persistent shortage or failing process cannot be corrected simply by asking the next shift to communicate better.

Review what is still open on your unit

Before your next shift change, choose one concern that has appeared in more than one shift report. Check its current status and identify who is responsible for the next action. Confirm that the receiving supervisor understands what remains to be done and when it needs attention.

When the matter is resolved, verify the result and inform the people affected. If it remains unresolved, make its status and next step clear enough that the next shift can continue the work.

The officer in the opening example already did the right thing by reporting the problem. Reliable supervision means that report starts a response the facility carries through to completion. No officer should have to restart that response every time the shift changes.

References

  1. McGuire, D. L., Jr. (2026, November 1). Before you lead the unit, learn to lead yourself. Corrections1.
  2. McGuire, D. L., Jr. (2026). Hard Reset: Reliability Under Pressure. Crosstown Coaching LLC.
  3. Campbell, N. M. (2006). Correctional Leadership Competencies for the 21st Century: Manager and Supervisor Levels. National Institute of Corrections. See Chapter 4 and Appendix 8–1.

About the author

Dr. Danny L. McGuire, Jr. is a retired Chicago Police Department sergeant whose experience includes undercover narcotics, Special Operations/HBT, SWAT support through the Weapons of Mass Destruction Safety and Support Team, and service as a chief hostage/crisis negotiator. He is the founder of Crosstown Coaching, and his books include “Hard Reset: Reliability Under Pressure” and “Leadership in Public Service: The ASCEND Method.” He serves as executive director of the Public Service Institute at Calumet College of St. Joseph and director of First Responder Wellness for Jacquelyn Augustine & Associates. He is an ICF Professional Certified Coach and an Illinois licensed professional counselor. Contact him at danny@drdanny.com.