By Michael Karlik
The Gazette (Colorado Springs, Colo.)
DENVER — The Denver-based federal appeals court ruled last week that a man serving a life sentence at Colorado’s “Supermax” prison could not sue the officials who allegedly disregarded his dental, dietary, and medical care, relying on the U.S. Supreme Court’s recent directive to bar such claims from the courthouse.
Mostafa Kamel Mostafa, also known as Abu Hamza, arrived at the U.S. Penitentiary — Administrative Maximum Facility in Florence in 2015. A British citizen, Mostafa was extradited to the United States and convicted of hostage taking, providing material support to terrorists, and conspiring to provide goods and services to the Taliban.
As an inmate at the highly secure prison, he alleged multiple constitutional violations, ranging from prison staff assaulting him and failing to accommodate the exercise of his Muslim faith to withholding basic hygiene items from Mostafa — who, as a double amputee, has difficulty functioning with his prosthetic arms.
As for his claim that prison officials violated his Eighth Amendment right against cruel and unusual punishment, Mostafa alleged that they were deliberately indifferent to his serious medical needs. Specifically, Mostafa alleged he lost 11 teeth because he had to open food packets with his mouth. He is also unable to clean himself, change his socks or cut his toenails, and has suffered infections from lack of adequate medical care.
However, those allegations directly clashed with the Supreme Court’s treatment of “Bivens claims,” which are lawsuits seeking money damages against federal employees for constitutional violations.
Bivens claims originated with a 1971 Supreme Court decision, Bivens v. Six Unknown Named Agents. In total, the Supreme Court has recognized three instances where Bivens claims are possible: unreasonable searches and seizures, sex discrimination, and deliberate indifference to an inmate’s serious medical needs that results in their death.
But a string of decisions, most recently in 2022, sent a clear message from the Supreme Court to lower courts: Lawsuits holding federal employees individually liable for unconstitutional conduct will usually fail.
“Bivens is now all but dead,” wrote Judge Timothy M. Tymkovich in a 2024 decision of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 10th Circuit, rejecting a plaintiff’s claim that prison officials were deliberately indifferent by waiting two years to perform hernia surgery on him.
Some federal judges in Colorado have pushed back against the curtailment of Bivens claims, noting that unconstitutional conduct by state prison officials is not shielded as it is for identical conduct in federal facilities.
“Under the rationale,” wrote Chief U.S. Magistrate Judge Scott T. Varholak, “a federal prison official may sadistically beat an inmate to within an inch of his life and that inmate will not have a civil remedy against that prison official.”
However, in Mostafa’s case, U.S. District Court Judge Philip A. Brimmer agreed that his allegations were a “new context” not covered by previous Bivens cases. While one Supreme Court case, Carlson v. Green, green-lit a Bivens claim where the alleged deliberate indifference of prison staff led to a man’s death, Brimmer noted that Mostafa’s allegations were different. Further, Mostafa could file an internal grievance with the prison instead.
After all of Mostafa’s claims were dismissed, he appealed Brimmer’s order, arguing that he filed at least 423 internal grievances to no avail.
“The Supreme Court has emphasized that the question isn’t whether you were successful in those proceedings,” said Judge Carolyn B. McHugh during oral arguments to a three-judge 10th Circuit panel. “The question is whether the process is available.”
“How can we disregard our precedent to do what you’re asking us to do?” added Judge Richard E.N. Federico.
Case: Mostafa v. Blanche
Decided: November 2, 2026
Jurisdiction: U.S. District Court for Colorado
Ruling: 3-0
Judges: Carolyn B. McHugh (author)
Scott M. Matheson Jr .
Richard E.N. Federico
Paul Wolf, representing Mostafa, suggested that the 10th Circuit hold off on issuing a decision because the Supreme Court is hearing a similar case involving deliberate indifference to a prisoner’s medical needs, and it is a “red-hot issue.”
“This is not a red-hot issue. The Supreme Court, in 40 years, has not found a new Bivens cause of action,” responded Assistant U.S. Attorney William Morrison.
“What’s Mr. Mostafa’s remedy here? If we take the allegations as true, they’re not opening his food packets, he can no longer use his prosthetics,” said McHugh. “He can’t engage in normal sanitary behaviors when he uses the toilet. I mean, where do they go from here?”
Morrison said that by choosing to argue a Bivens claim, Mostafa had foregone other paths to relief.
“Forever?” asked McHugh. “Can they continue to let him lose weight because he can’t eat and have sanitary issues?”
Ultimately, the 10th Circuit panel agreed that Mostafa was pursuing a new Bivens claim that the Supreme Court has not recognized.
“Mr. Mostafa alleged poor dental care, poor podiatric care, denial of his medical diet, inadequate prosthetics, failure to provide a mask, and untimely renewal of prescription medications. Although these conditions are serious and concerning,” wrote McHugh in a Nov. 2 opinion, they were “unlike the complete denial of care and mistreatment in Carlson that led to (the prisoner’s) death.”
The case is Mostafa v. Blanche et al.
—
© 2026 The Gazette (Colorado Springs, Colo.). Visit www.gazette.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.