Trending Topics

Balancing faith and security: Religious accommodation under RLUIPA

Two Supreme Court decisions offer correctional administrators a framework for evaluating religious accommodation requests while maintaining institutional safety and security

African American prisoner reads Bible, turns pages

EvgeniyShkolenko/Getty Images

By Malik Muhammad, Ed.D.

John Ramirez was on death row in Texas after being convicted of capital murder and sentenced to death. After receiving notification of his execution date, Ramirez requested that his spiritual advisor, Pastor Dana Moore, be allowed in the execution chamber. At the time, the Texas Department of Criminal Justice’s execution protocol did not permit spiritual advisors inside the chamber.

Texas later amended its execution protocol to allow spiritual advisors inside the execution chamber. [1] Ramirez then requested that his spiritual advisor be permitted to pray over him and lay hands on him during the execution. Texas denied the request for physical contact. Ramirez’s attorney later asked whether Moore would be permitted to pray audibly during the execution. After prison officials denied that request, Ramirez amended his federal complaint to seek both accommodations. [2]

While pursuing internal procedures at the prison and awaiting the outcome of a Step 2 grievance, Ramirez also filed suit in federal court, alleging violations of the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act of 2000 (RLUIPA) and the First Amendment. Ramirez sought preliminary and permanent injunctive relief barring Texas from executing him without the requested accommodations. He also requested a stay of execution while the district court considered his claims.

Both the district court and the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit denied his request for a stay of execution. On September 7, 2021, the day before his scheduled execution, Ramirez petitioned the Supreme Court of the United States for a stay. To obtain preliminary injunctive relief, Ramirez had to establish, among other legal requirements, that he was likely to succeed on the merits of his RLUIPA claims. Once Ramirez demonstrated that the restrictions substantially burdened sincere religious exercise, Texas bore the burden of showing that the restrictions were the least restrictive means of furthering compelling governmental interests. [3]

After review, the Supreme Court stayed the execution, granted certiorari and heard argument in Ramirez v. Collier, 595 U.S. 411 (2022), on an expedited basis. In its decision, the Supreme Court reversed the Fifth Circuit’s judgment, remanded the case and concluded that Ramirez was likely to succeed on the merits of his RLUIPA claims. [2]

The Supreme Court’s decision in Ramirez illustrates a recurring challenge for correctional institutions: determining when restrictions imposed for safety and institutional security unnecessarily burden religious exercise. The question is whether meaningful religious accommodation can coexist with institutional security and the orderly administration of correctional institutions, without treating either interest as absolute.

The legal framework for the decision was previously applied in Holt v. Hobbs, 574 U.S. 352 (2015), in which the Supreme Court considered an Arkansas Department of Correction (ADOC) grooming policy that prohibited an incarcerated Muslim from growing a half-inch beard in accordance with his stated religious beliefs. Administrators argued that the restriction was necessary to prevent incarcerated individuals from hiding contraband and disguising their identities. Although the Court recognized Arkansas’s compelling security interests, it concluded that the department had not demonstrated that prohibiting Holt’s half-inch beard was the least restrictive means of furthering those interests. [4]

Ramirez builds on Holt by reaffirming that courts consider correctional expertise without automatically accepting generalized security assertions. A claimant must first demonstrate that a governmental restriction substantially burdens sincere religious exercise. The government must then establish that the restriction is the least restrictive means of furthering a compelling governmental interest. Accordingly, administrators considering a request for religious accommodation must evaluate the claimant, the identified institutional risk and the feasibility of less restrictive alternatives. [2]

From legal standards to administrative practice

The decisions in Holt and Ramirez were not intended to compromise institutional security or require administrators to abandon safety or best practices. Instead, both landmark decisions emphasize the value of an individualized, systematic and well-vetted process for evaluating requests for religious accommodation. Developing a standardized process for evaluating potential risks also promotes transparency, accountability and consistency.

As part of the review process, administrators are encouraged to:

  1. Clarify the request: Identify the religious practice, duration, location, participants and required items.
  2. Confirm religious exercise: Determine whether the request is sincerely motivated by a religious belief.
  3. Assess the substantial burden: Consider whether denial or restriction would significantly prevent or limit the practice or pressure the individual to violate a religious belief.
  4. Identify the compelling governmental interest: Define the specific safety, security, administrative or operational concern using facts rather than generalized assertions.
  5. Consider the least restrictive means: Determine whether the institutional interest can be achieved through an alternative that places a lesser burden on religious exercise.
  6. Document the decision: Record the request, evidence reviewed, institutional interest, alternatives considered and rationale for the final decision.

Establish a clear and timely review process

As a best practice, correctional administrators should establish a clear written process through which requests for religious accommodation may be submitted. The process should be easy to understand and designed to address routine requests as well as concerns requiring escalated administrative review. Normally, requests should be submitted in writing. The institution should provide appropriate assistance to individuals facing language, literacy or disability-related barriers. Requests should be reviewed promptly and time- and date-stamped to establish a clear timeline.

The review process should also identify the practical information needed to evaluate the request, such as special diets, religious clothing, a spiritual advisor, physical accommodations or ceremonial requirements that require staff assistance. After reviewing the request and making a determination, administrators should provide a formal written decision explaining the outcome. All actions taken during the review process should be documented and preserved for future reviews or potential litigation.

Identifying protected religious exercise

Under the RLUIPA framework, administrators can assess whether an accommodation request is based on a sincerely held religious belief or a secular preference. However, they may not judge whether the stated belief is logical, orthodox, widely known or required by an established faith. [5] The framework does not prohibit administrators from asking neutral questions or considering inconsistencies in the request. Nor should verification from a spiritual advisor serve as the sole proof of religious sincerity.

As demonstrated in Ramirez v. Collier, inconsistent statements do not automatically invalidate a request when the overall information supports religious sincerity. [2] Substantial burden and religious sincerity are separate issues and should be treated as such.

After determining that the stated belief is sincere, administrators should assess whether denying or restricting the request would pressure the individual to abandon, modify or violate the religious practice. The review should distinguish between a restriction that effectively prohibits the practice and a reasonable time, place or manner alternative that would still meet the individual’s needs. As in Holt v. Hobbs, providing access to other opportunities for religious exercise does not remove the burden of addressing the specific practice requested.

Addressing security concerns with specific evidence

Generalized references to cost, security or orderly administration are insufficient without an explanation connecting the requested accommodation to a specific institutional risk. Administrators must identify the specific harm the restriction is intended to prevent and explain how the accommodation would create that risk. The analysis should be specific to the individual request and identify any relevant institutional history considered in reaching the decision. It should also address the likelihood and potential severity of the identified harm.

As a best practice, the review should consider previous accommodations made for others and whether the institution can safely permit religious exercise without compromising a compelling governmental interest. Administrators should not simply state that an accommodation poses a security risk; they should clearly articulate their concerns. The decision must connect the requested accommodation to the potential harm and explain why less restrictive alternatives would not be sufficient.

Evaluating less restrictive means

An accommodation review should not be viewed as a choice between unconditional approval and complete denial. If a request raises a legitimate institutional concern, administrators should determine whether an alternative accommodation can address the risk. The claimant must first show that the policy substantially burdens sincere religious exercise. The institution must then demonstrate that imposing the burden on that claimant furthers a compelling governmental interest and is the least restrictive means of doing so. [3]

Depending on the request, administrators should consider various measures when evaluating the least restrictive means of accommodating religious exercise. In Ramirez v. Collier, the Supreme Court concluded that Texas had not shown that its restrictions on audible prayer and religious touch were the least restrictive means of furthering its compelling governmental interests. The Court identified possible safeguards, including limiting the volume of audible prayer, requiring silence during critical moments and restricting where and for how long physical contact may occur.

Creating a transparent record of review

Documenting religious accommodation decisions is a best practice, whether a request is approved, denied or approved with conditions. The decision should identify the accommodation requested, the information considered, findings on sincerity and substantial burden, specific institutional concerns and evidence supporting the identified risk. If applicable, it should also address less restrictive alternatives and explain why they were accepted or rejected.

To strengthen the review, administrators should consult chaplains, operational staff, medical professionals and legal advisers as appropriate. RLUIPA does not require a multidisciplinary review process; [3] the recommendation is intended to promote continuity and informed decision-making.

Ensuring consistency across the tnstitution

Efforts to establish a legally sound accommodation review process can fail when staff are not included or do not understand the policy’s purpose. Another best practice is to train employees on the RLUIPA framework, including substantial burden, compelling governmental interest and the least restrictive means standard. Training should emphasize that an accommodation request may trigger statutory obligations under RLUIPA when denying or restricting it would substantially burden sincere religious exercise. [5]

Policies should be reviewed and updated to ensure consistency with statutory requirements and identify the officials authorized to approve, deny or conditionally approve accommodation requests. [3] Facility chaplains may provide input on the nature of a request; however, RLUIPA does not require their concurrence for administrative approval.

These recommendations may help prevent arbitrary restrictions based on differing religious views, implicit bias or unfamiliarity with RLUIPA while reducing the likelihood of grievances and litigation.

In conclusion

Religious exercise and institutional security can coexist when administrators use a disciplined, well-vetted approach to reviewing accommodation requests. Public safety practitioners understand that security remains a legitimate and compelling concern, and courts consider the expertise of agency officials. However, courts have not accepted generalized claims of institutional safety concerns. Specific risks, the circumstances of the request and less restrictive alternatives must all be evaluated, increasing the likelihood of a defensible decision.

References

1. Texas Department of Criminal Justice, Correctional Institutions Division. Execution procedure. Texas Department of Criminal Justice; 2021.
2. Supreme Court of the United States. Ramirez v Collier, 595 US 411 (2022). Decided March 24, 2022.
3. 42 USC § 2000cc-1. Protection of religious exercise of institutionalized persons. Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act of 2000.
4. Supreme Court of the United States. Holt v Hobbs, 574 US 352 (2015). Decided January 20, 2015.
5. US Department of Justice, Civil Rights Division. Religious land use and institutionalized persons. Published August 6, 2015.

About the author

Malik Muhammad, Ed.D., is a correctional executive, educator, author and retired U.S. Army reservist with more than two decades of leadership experience in public safety. He serves as a correctional major with the Orange County Corrections Department, overseeing facility operations, personnel, policy, fiscal management and regulatory compliance. Since 2005, Dr. Muhammad has also taught criminal justice as an adjunct professor at Valencia College. He holds a Doctor of Education from the University of New England, where his research examined the lived experiences of correctional educators. A nationally credentialed jail manager, correctional manager and trainer, he has presented at major criminal justice conferences and contributed to publications on jail leadership, incarcerated veterans, correctional education and recidivism reduction. His work reflects a sustained commitment to ethical leadership, professional development and improved outcomes within correctional systems.