By DON THOMPSON
The Associated Press
Calif. prison healthcare supe wants $8 billion for medical facilities
Prison healthcare plan spawns opposition in So. Cal.
Innovative medical facility proposed at Calif. prison
SAN FRANCISCO, Calif. — A federal judge scolded California officials on Monday for failing to provide the billions of dollars a court-appointed receiver says is needed to upgrade the state’s prison health care system.
U.S. District Judge Thelton Henderson made it clear he expects California to pay $8 billion for seven new inmate medical facilities. But he stopped short of immediately holding Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger and state Controller John Chiang in contempt for failing to turn over the money.
The judge says he is likely to order the state to pay $250 million as a first installment to demonstrate good faith.
J. Clark Kelso, the receiver, said he needs that amount to start designing three new medical and mental health units. Kelso said he will need more than $3 billion before July 1 to begin building them. The rest of the $8 billion would come in later years.
“He needs the money to run it and improve it,” Henderson said as he repeatedly dismissed objections from the state’s deputy attorney general.
He noted a sense of urgency to reform California’s delivery of inmate medical care and said the price tag to fix it should not be an obstacle.
“Defendants’ argument would seem to allow federal constitutional rights to be trampled any time a state decides it would cost too much money,” he said at the opening of the hearing.
Medical care in California’s prisons is so bad it has been ruled unconstitutional. Henderson appointed a receiver to run the prison medical system after finding that an average of an inmate a week was dying from neglect or malpractice.
The judge said he suspects that “nothing more than political intermeddling” is blocking the state from paying the money. He criticized the Schwarzenegger administration for its “11th hour change of heart” in opposing prison health care facilities it had supported until recently.
Kelso asked the judge to give the state one more chance to make a down payment in two weeks. The judge said he will issue a written order on that request within days.
“Show us the green,” James Brosnahan, Kelso’s attorney, quipped to reporters after the hour-long hearing. “We could hold them in contempt today if we wanted to. (Instead), we want to move very cautiously.”
Henderson said it is no excuse that the state Legislature balked repeatedly this year at approving a borrowing plan that would have spread payments for the $8 billion over 25 years.
“They’re not even starting, they’re not even on the road where I want to go,” Henderson said of reluctant lawmakers.
The $8 billion for improving health care for prison inmates is nearly as much as the entire annual budget of the state Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation, which will be a little more than $10.3 billion this fiscal year.
That lawmakers failed to agree to the prison-spending request is no surprise. They were overwhelmed this summer by a $15.2 billion budget deficit that led to the longest budget impasse in state history.
California is expected to have financial problems for years to come, especially as the state and national economies continue their slide.
Deputy Attorney General Daniel Powell said the administration believes it needs a specific court order if it is to bypass the Legislature and turn over the money.
“I can do that by lunchtime,” Henderson interrupted.
The judge also rejected Powell’s promises that the state will try again with the new Legislature that will take office after the November elections.
Nor was he placated by lawmakers’ passing a $7.4 billion prison construction package last year that includes money for the medical beds. Issuing the bonds has been stalled by legal hurdles and legislative inaction.
“That’s been in existence for two years. We haven’t gotten a cent from it,” Henderson interjected as Powell tried to explain.
The judge said the state also has “an uphill battle” in objecting to the cost and scale of the construction because the Schwarzenegger administration initially went along with Kelso’s plans.
Powell, the deputy attorney general, said the administration always expected to pay by borrowing money. It already faces a “dire financial situation” with the deteriorating economy and projected deficits.
“The state simply doesn’t have the money to pay ... on a pay-as-you-go basis,” Powell said. He denied that politics played a role.
Schwarzenegger spokeswoman Lisa Page said the administration would not comment until it sees Henderson’s written order.
Assemblyman Todd Spitzer, R-Orange, who has led legislative Republicans in objecting to court intervention in the prison system, said his members would appeal if Henderson orders the state to turn over any money.
The lawmakers are not involved in the lawsuit, but Spitzer said they would support an appeal by the state or try to intervene independently. He advocated for a special legislative session to address prison problems.
“We still believe this is the province of the Legislature,” said Spitzer, R-Orange.
Legislative Republicans and the state attorney general’s office argue that federal law prohibits judges from ordering states to pay for prison construction. Kelso, the court-appointed receiver, says fixing constitutional problems supersedes the federal law.